TOCFL vs HSK: how to choose the right Chinese exam
If you are applying to a programme in Taiwan, begin by checking its TOCFL requirement. For programmes in China, look at the HSK. While the exams share some similarities, they test different skills and report levels differently.
On this page · 10 sections
Choose by where you need the result
The receiving university, scholarship office or employer makes the sensible choice for you. Taiwan programmes commonly name TOCFL, while mainland Chinese programmes and scholarship notices name HSK. Some institutions accept an alternative: National Taiwan University, for example, lists HSK 4 alongside TOCFL A2 for Chinese-medium degree admission.
After you know which exam your institution accepts, look at what each test measures. The main difference is the skills each certificate demonstrates.
What each exam tests
TOCFL tests listening and reading separately. If you need your speaking or writing skills assessed, you can take those tests separately. In Band A, if you take the combined listening and reading test, your certificate will show the lower of your two skill levels, as long as you also meet the total and individual minimum scores.
HSK builds more skills into the test as levels rise. HSK 1 to 2 cover listening and reading. HSK 3 to 6 add writing. HSK 7 to 9 combine listening, reading, writing, translation and speaking.
The HSK Speaking Test (HSKK) is a separate option at lower levels. TOCFL listening uses everyday situations. Advanced HSK tasks draw on academic or news material and include chart writing, translation and spoken responses.
How the scores and certificates work
TOCFL listening and reading sections use scaled scores. In the computer-adaptive test, later questions are chosen based on your estimated ability. For a Level 2 certificate, you need a total score of 117, with at least 49 in listening and 53 in reading. The adaptive version uses a different scale: 885 overall, with minimums of 395 in listening and 415 in reading.
To pass HSK 1 or 2, you need 120 out of 200 points. For HSK 3 or 4, you need 180 out of 300. HSK 7 to 9 results are classified as below Level 7, or at Level 7, 8, or 9. The scoring systems for TOCFL and HSK do not directly match.
Based on current information, the Ministry of Education does not set a general expiry period for TOCFL certificates. HSK 1 to 6 results are valid for two years from the exam date. CTI’s HSK 7 to 9 page does not mention a validity period. Universities or employers may set their own rules about how recent your result must be.
How TOCFL and HSK compare with CEFR
TOCFL officially aligns Level 1 with CEFR A1 through Level 6 with C2. HSK 3.0 has no official CEFR conversion in the syllabus, and the current CTI level information reviewed for this guide is not included.
Older charts compare CEFR with HSK 2.0, not the HSK 3.0 syllabus that started in July 2026. HSK 7 to 9 use the same exam and advanced vocabulary list. The sources do not give an exact HSK match for TOCFL C1 or C2.
| CEFR | TOCFL | HSK 3.0, approximate |
|---|---|---|
| Below A1 | Preparatory | HSK 1 |
| A1 | TOCFL A1 | HSK 2 |
| A2 | TOCFL A2 | HSK 3 |
| B1 | TOCFL B1 | HSK 4–5 |
| B2 | TOCFL B2 | HSK 6 |
| C1 | TOCFL C1 | HSK 7–8 |
| C2 | TOCFL C2 | Upper HSK 8–9 |
Where the results count for university and scholarships
The test and level you need depend on your programme and the award. Taiwan’s Ministry of Education (MOE) sets TOCFL A2 as the minimum for most Chinese-medium programmes, but some programmes have higher requirements. In China, HSK requirements differ by university and scholarship.
| Route | Test requirement | Applies to |
|---|---|---|
| National Taiwan University | TOCFL A2 or HSK 4 | Chinese-medium degree admission |
| Taiwan Scholarship · MOE | TOCFL Level 3 / Advanced or equivalent | Non-English-taught degree |
| Taiwan Scholarship · MOFA | TOCFL Level 2 in listening and reading | Direct entry to Chinese-medium degree |
| Huayu Enrichment Scholarship | TOCFL Level 3 / Advanced | Awards of at least nine months |
| Tsinghua University | HSK 5+; at least 60 in each subject | Chinese-English-taught undergraduate programme; English proficiency also required |
| Chinese Government Scholarship (CSC) · bilateral · 2026/27 | HSK 3 | Chinese-taught undergraduate, general scholar and senior scholar routes |
| Chinese Government Scholarship (CSC) · bilateral · 2026/27 | HSK 4 | Chinese-taught master’s and doctoral routes |
Check the conditions attached to each award.
For the MOE Taiwan Scholarship, the overseas mission may allow an exception if TOCFL is not available. If you do not have the result, you must pass Level 3 or an equivalent test at your own expense in your first semester and submit it to your university. Preparatory award students in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) route must reach Level 2 in listening and reading by next June to remain eligible for their degree scholarship.
Huayu Enrichment Scholarship recipients need a Level 3 result from the past two years. If you do not have this, you must take at least Level 3 after you arrive and submit the result to your language centre before the last month. If you do not, one month of the award will be suspended.
The CSC HSK 3 route does not include Chinese-language study for general scholars. Applicants must also meet the host university’s requirements. The 2026/27 notice does not say which HSK syllabus edition it uses.
How employers and work routes use the tests
The employment examples depend on the region. In Taiwan, the Steering Committee for the Test of Proficiency-Huayu (SC-TOP) lists TOCFL levels for certain employers and jobs. In China, Chinese Testing International (CTI) lists HSK for recruitment, training, and promotion, and as proof of Chinese ability for employers and government officials.
| Use | TOCFL · Taiwan | HSK · China |
|---|---|---|
| Hiring | Role-specific levels; recruitment and staff assignment | Recruitment, training and promotion |
| Work retention / visa | Graduate points route; migrant-worker test route | Work- and visa-related uses; requirements set by the relevant authority |
Verdict: follow the requirement you need to meet
For study or work in Taiwan, start with the TOCFL requirement and check whether the institution accepts HSK instead. For China, check the university, employer or scholarship rules for the exact HSK version and level.
Questions about TOCFL and HSK
Are TOCFL and HSK levels equivalent?
No direct conversion makes the certificates interchangeable. TOCFL publishes its own CEFR alignment, while HSK 3.0 has no official CEFR conversion in the syllabus. Follow the level named by the organisation receiving your result.
Which exam should I take for Taiwan?
Check the programme or employer requirement first. TOCFL is the Taiwan proficiency test, and some institutions accept HSK as an alternative for specific routes.
Can I use HSK for an application in Taiwan?
Some institutions list HSK alongside TOCFL for particular applications. National Taiwan University, for example, lists HSK 4 alongside TOCFL A2 for Chinese-medium degree admission. Confirm the current rule for your programme before booking.
Sources
Practise exam vocabulary using Shufa.
Shufa includes TOCFL vocabulary by level and lists for both HSK 2.0 and HSK 3.0. Practise the list that corresponds to the exam you plan to take. You can open the app for free at https://app.shufa.study/.